It's no secret that I am Not a fan of reboots. Leave Stuff Alone! And after my disappointment with Netflix's reboot of She-Ra (Why does everybody know that Aurora is She-Ra? That mystery was what made that cartoon special in the 1980s), I was fearful to watch The BabySitter's Club. I remember the summer before I entered 4th grade was when I read my first BSC book. I fell in love with it instantly. I also liked the HBO show & theatrical movie based on the books by Ann Martin.
I have a weird placement in my family. I'm the youngest of my mom's children, but one of the middle grandchildren. And being a girl between boys, many times I had to play by myself. I didn't want to play cars & Transformers all the time. By the time I was 9, I was totally over my grandmother's "fun" summertime activities (learning the books of the Bible & embroidery, snapping beans, and washing the good china). The only activities she & I agreed on was reading & crossword puzzles.
So, I immersed myself in the world of books. The BabySitters Club series were some of the residents there. It was fun to read about girls babysitting. Most of my babysitters were elderly ladies & my sister. So, this was very different from my life. I always related to Mary Anne Spier. I wasn't shy as a child but I was still observational and I was kinda an "in a clutch"-type of person. I could/would step in so things wouldn't be messed up. Also weirdly enough I understood Janine, the older, nerdy sister of Claudia, the creative member of BSC. Though she was know-it-all wasn't mean in my eyes.
So, I sat down one late Sunday morning after church and watched the Netflix series. I avoided all think pieces, reviews, & interviews. I watched it with the fresh 40+ eyes of a book fan from long ago. I am happy I did. This modern take on BSC is refreshing. It's nostalgia for the old book lovers and a curtain-raiser for new perspectives. It takes the same path as the books with a big idea from one, expands to the main 5 members, and ends with the introduction of two more members. Each episode is told by the viewpoint of the storyline's main character like the books. There were still the universal storylines of crushes on boys, school & grades, growing up/puberty, and relatives getting older. There is the iconic clear landline phone that rings during the meetings. *ring, ring* Babysitters Club!
Oh Kristy, is still a tomboy with no sexuality assigned to her in middle school. (One day, I will have to talk about my annoyance with Hollywood trying to change the tomboy narrative & definition.) But as times have changed, some of the social issues & behaviors are different than those of the 80s & 90s. I chuckled when one of the members is punished and has to rely on a Mingo phone for communications. Also, the characters are more inclusive. Claudia & Jessi are not the only non-white BSC member. Spoiler alert: Mary Anne is biracial (Black & White) & Dawn is Latina. And the new look was not jarring for me, because the characters still act the same. That another reason why I didn't engage with anything think-pieces & reviews beforehand. I didn't want to be ticked off at any possible tone-deaf, non-book readers with an opinion.
There are also diverse types of families that need babysitters in the community. BSC Netflix answers the question, " What is a Family" very well.
A Season 2 must happen. I will windmill Netflix if it does not. We were only introduced to Mallory & Jessi becoming junior members. And they are both very important. Jessi was a black member. I may have identified mostly like Mary Anne, but I was very happy to see a black girl appear in the books. Representation has Always been important. And Mallory was also significant. Mallory was one of their clients who had a huge family. She is the only one from such a big household. And her voice is vital also.
Well, let me look at what others are saying. I'm probably the only 40+ person openly talking about this show. Keyword is...
Oh well if you will watching or have watched The BabySitters Club, let me know in the comments here or on the social media site you see this post on. And who was your favorite from the book and the show? Let's discuss our fandom.
As Always Talking to You in Adult Terms!!!











